Mass Comparators

1. What is the definition of a comparator?

A mass comparator or comparator balance is a balance with best possible resolution and repeatability allowing determining even the smallest difference is mass. While window-range mass comparators are purely used for mass calibration and mass determination, full-range mass comparators are versatile and can be used for weight determination but as well for general weighing applications where small samples meet large tare loads or the large and small amounts need to be combined in one weighing process. Contact your local METTLER TOLEDO representative to receive a GWP Recommendation identifying the models suiting your personal needs.

2.  What makes mass calibration so different?

In a regular weighing process, the balanced is calibrated and the individual weighing are against zero g, therefore the process is called "absolute weighing". With weight calibration, which is a specific type of differential weighing, the reference point is not the calibrated comparator balance; it's the reference weight against which the test weight is compared to. Reference weight need to be at least one weight class higher than the test weight. Each of the reference weights is again calibrated against another weight of higher class resulting to a metrological traceability to the definition of the kilogram based on Planck's constant.

3. What applications are comparators used for?

The primary applications where mass comparators are used for is mass calibration. For lower class weights, in particular M 1-3, F1 & 2 classes, manual mass comparators provide results of sufficient accuracy. For weights of E1 or E2 class it is recommended to use either robotic or automated mass comparators as the measurement uncertainty is significantly lower, this mainly due to the obsolescence of the operators influence. In national metrology institutes (NMI's), which strive continuously for measurements with smallest uncertainty, vacuum or constant pressure mass comparators are utilized as these allow performing measurements at constant conditions. Influences such as geographic altitude, air buoyancy or weather conditions can be eliminated. National metrology institutes and metrology research center apply mass comparators for scientific research to measure smallest changes in mass or force.

Besides the metrology application mass comparator are as well in use in other industries where the performance of a regular balance cannot meet the customer demand. For these applications the comparators are referred to as higher performance balances.

Some of these industrial applications are:

• Formulation – if tolerance levels are low and the save weighing range of the balance does not fulfil the instrument demands
• Differential weighing applications – if the difference in mass is very small and an ordinary balance cannot provide trustworthy results
• Gas filling – Heavy gas bottles are filled with a small amount of precious reference gas
• Scuffing – Gears are analyzed on abrasion after the engine was run for a specified time in the lubricant of investigation
• Force measurements – Measurements where an applied force is compensated by the weighing cell

4. What is the difference between a mass comparator and a balance?

Mass Comparators are of identical design and principle as an electronic balance. What differentiates the balance to the comparator is the performance, in particular the readability and repeatability.

• Precision Balance with 1 kg capacity and 1 mg readability
• Manual mass comparator / Higher performance balance with 1 kg capacity and 0.1 mg readability
• Window-range mass comparator 1 kg capacity and 0.01 mg readability
• Automated mass comparator 1 kg capacity and 0.001 mg readability
• Constant/ Vacuum mass comparators 1 kg capacity and 0.0001 mg readability

Regular laboratory balances are specified by the main properties repeatability (RP), eccentricity (EC), nonlinearity (NL) and sensitivity (SE). As weight calibration is subject of differential weighing mass comparators are additionally specified with differential weighing repeatability ABA (RP ABA).

5. How to calibrate a mass comparator?

According to regulations, Mass Comparators in use for mass calibration do not need to be calibrated, as the reference weight is calibrated and ensures for traceability to the BIPM and the definition of the kilogram. To protect your investment and ensure continuous constant measurement performance, METTLER TOELDO recommends performing preventive maintenance on a routine base.

Where mass comparators are in use in applications different than weight calibration, it is crucial to apply existing quality standards on the XPR-C balances, identical to other analytical or precision balances.